Oprah Winfrey participates in “Oprah’s 2020 Vision: Your Life in Focus” tour at the Barclays Center on Saturday, Februty 8, 2020, in New York. (Photo by Brad Barket/Invision/AP)
TUCSON, Ariz. (AP) — Oprah Winfrey’s soon-to-be televised discussion about the controversial novel American Dirt is drawing scrutiny for not inviting some of the book’s harshest Latino critics.
The talk show host organized her much-hyped conversation with author Jeanine Cummins on Thursday after inviting around 250 people to the Harkins Theatres Arizona Pavilions in southern Arizona, the Arizona Daily Star reports. The crowd was then directed to another Tucson, Arizona, location and asked to sign a nondisclosure agreement.
The discussion will be the next episode in Winfrey’s new Apple TV+ series Oprah’s Book Club, which features personal conversations with authors in front of a live audience.
Details of the gathering were not known since the audience was banned from speaking about the event until after the show airs in March.
The novel about a Mexican mother and her young son fleeing to the U.S. border had been praised widely before its January 21 release. But anger built over allegations the book relied on stereotypes, caricatures, and material similar to another Latino writer.
Latino critics also blasted promotions at book release parties that had floral art centerpieces with barbed wire mimicking the border wall.
Oprah chose the novel for her book club shortly after its release, drawing more anger from Latino critics.
In a video posted on Instagram following the criticism, Winfrey said she now realizes the book struck “an emotional chord” with Latinos and created a need for deeper conversation.
On Wednesday, the group #DignidadLiteraria posted an open letter to Winfrey on the site Literary Hub calling for deeper conversations about “the continued underrepresentation of (Latino) authors in publishing and in your highly influential book club.”
The letter mentioned the Tucson event and called for a private meeting with Winfrey and their movement.
“We urge to you open your mind and heart to actual Latinos the way you have publicly declared you did to Jeanine’s fictional characters,” the letter read.
Writer Roberto Lovato, one of the signers of the letter, wrote on Twitter about not receiving an invitation to Winfrey’s Tucson event.
“People are starting to enter @Oprah’s ‘all sides,’ completely staged #AmericanDirt spectacle for @AppleTV in Tucson. Though we were not invited & though we r interested in talking re industry, not spectacles, she will be hearing from #DignidadLiteraria,” he wrote.
People are starting to enter @Oprah's "all sides," completely staged #AmericanDirt spectacle for @AppleTV in Tucson. Though we were not invited & though we r interested in talking re industry, not spectacles, she will be hearing from #DignidadLiteraria. pic.twitter.com/7M5mZfZM86
— Roberto Lovato (@robvato) February 13, 2020
The episode, which is set to debut in March, is the third installment of the series. The first two episodes were hour-long conversations with book club authors Ta-Nehisi Coates and Elizabeth Strout.
Oprah, so disappointed in you to endorse a book written by somebody that knows zero about our culture. You would not approve somebody making a seven figure payment to a writer if it was your culture being written so inappropriate. I have been your fan forever, but this just made me so sad. Wish you have taken the time to to speak and explore with Latino and Latina writers, historians or just Mexican
human beings. Would you like it if somebody wrote that Stedman courted you with watermelon. Too late, but maybe you could learn for the future.
She built her “career” patronizing constipated Chicago suburban housewives for decades and counseling them about their cross-dressing tranny husbands ..and then giving them all cars at the end of the show.
The only “La Tinos” she knows about are those spit-shining the marble floors on her yacht.
And you expect her to have journalistic integrity?
Really?
Really?
Really?
That’s as foolish as expecting Barry-Hussein to turn his Martha’s Vineyard mansion into a half-house for wayward Eskimos.