On Monday evening, the White House and Centers for Disease Control released new coronavirus guidelines asking Americans to “avoid social gathering in groups of 10 people,” keep schooling at home, avoid non-essential travel, and advicing that elderly people stay at home. The guidelines are some of the most specific ones that the Trump administration had shared with the public.
Close to 18 hours after these guidelines were announced, there is still no official government Spanish version of the guidelines, and according to the White House, there was no indication as to when an official Spanish version will be made available to the public, as well as other official languages.
Latino Rebels contacted the White House on Monday night. The White House acknowledged receipt of the request, but did not share any specific information about when the Spanish version will be made public, if indeed it will be made public.
12 hours after I asked @WhiteHouse where I can find the Spanish version of the new #COVID19 guidelines to share with the community, am still waiting.
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 17, 2020
A March 17 review of the CDC’s Spanish-language Coronavirus section is about 11 days behind the new guidelines shared by the White House and the CDC on March 16 through WhiteHouse.gov and Coronavirus.gov. The last Spanish-language informational piece about the virus made public was dated March 6.
In addition, the CDC’s Spanish-language Twitter profile is tweeting information about the virus but nothing so far about the new guidelines:
¿Está limpiando con productos desinfectantes esta semana? Recuerde nunca mezclar cloro de uso doméstico con amoníaco o cualquier otro limpiador. ¡Esta combinación puede crear vapores tóxicos y peligrosos! Obtenga más información importante: https://t.co/DKsyVslvSM pic.twitter.com/A3JRmSvcKj
— CDC Environment (@CDCEnvironment) March 16, 2020
Tómate el tiempo para lavarte las manos cuando manipules alimentos. Lavarse las manos por 20 segundos quizás parezca mucho tiempo, ¡pero ayuda a que tú y tu familia se mantengan sanos! https://t.co/Ak5AyvLg8G #ManténLasManosLimpias pic.twitter.com/hvr3CkycEr
— CDC en Español (@CDCespanol) March 9, 2020
The White House’s Spanish-language Twitter profile, La Casa Blanca, has yet to tweet anything about the CDC’s Spanish-language virus information page, except for a tweet about washing hands that came out on March 9.
Tómate el tiempo para lavarte las manos cuando manipules alimentos. Lavarse las manos por 20 segundos quizás parezca mucho tiempo, ¡pero ayuda a que tú y tu familia se mantengan sanos! https://t.co/Ak5AyvLg8G #ManténLasManosLimpias pic.twitter.com/hvr3CkycEr
— CDC en Español (@CDCespanol) March 9, 2020
Besides the washing hands tweet, the last two tweets from Casa Blanca profile was an English-language link to a White House tweet and a March 4 speech by President Trump to the Latino Coalition Legislative Summit.
El mensaje sobre coronavirus más importante en este momento: tome medidas de sentido común para protegerse y proteger a los demás. https://t.co/H1EBqY9NeQ
— USA en Español (@USAenEspanol) March 10, 2020
EN VIVO: El presidente @realDonaldTrump da un discurso ante el @LatinoCoalition, destacando las prioridades económicas y los logros que han beneficiado a las familias y los negocios latinos. https://t.co/J9WHmbD2Km
— La Casa Blanca (@LaCasaBlanca) March 4, 2020
Latino Rebels also contacted the CDC on Monday morning about when the new March 16 guidelines will be made available in Spanish and other languages. As of this posting, the CDC has not responded.
According to Pew, even though the number of Spanish speakers has decreased in the United States, a 2017 estimate said “37 million Latinos in the U.S. speak Spanish at home, making it the country’s most common non-English language.”
Despite the lack of official government guidelines in Spanish, several Spanish-language outlets are providing updates about the Monday news.
Via @elnuevoherald https://t.co/KxJ6mCRUzQ
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 17, 2020
Also, people are being encouraged to check local state and city resources, where more updated multiple language versions are being shared. For example, New York City has latest information in Spanish dated March 15. The city of San Francisco has translated information that was updated on March 16.
After the Trump administration said in early 2017 that a Spanish-language version of the White House’s official page would go live eventually, there is still no Spanish-language version three years later.
Latino Rebels plans to update this story if both the White House and/or the CDC respond to the multiple requests for information about updated Spanish-language guidelines.
UPDATE, March 17, 2:45 p.m. ET: After not tweeting since March 10, the Casa Blanca Twitter profile retweeted the following CDC en Español content about washing hands (which CDC en Español just tweeted), but nothing in Spanish about the new March 16 guidelines:
UPDATE, March 17, 4:50 p.m. ET: The Twitter profile of the Committee for Hispanic Causes’ (CHC) Political Action Committee announced that it had translated the March 16 guidelines on its own. NBC News wrote about the reactions from Latino advocacy groups.
The @WhiteHouse released its "Coronavirus Guidelines For America" in English: https://t.co/L9XRh50YKz
Since Trump failed to release them in Spanish, BOLD PAC decided to do it for him. Our families deserve access to public health info in a language they understand + trust. pic.twitter.com/1Gb0m8nAZj
— BOLD Democrats (@BOLDDems) March 17, 2020
UPDATE, March 17, 8:15 p.m. ET: Both the White House and the CDC have still not shared news about whether the March 16 guidelines are in Spanish. However, journalist José Delgado of El Nuevo Día has tweeted a screen shot of a translation that appears to be related to the new guidelines:
Las recomendaciones del gobierno federal que incluyen evitar reuniones de 10 o más personas. pic.twitter.com/gsP3R83HUJ
— José A. Delgado (@JoseADelgadoEND) March 17, 2020
UPDATE, March 17, 8:53 p.m. ET: Latino Rebels finally received a forwarded email from the White House about the translations:
So this is what they shared with journalists. It's not even designed yet. This is first part pic.twitter.com/oPjw4HUwaf
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 18, 2020
This is third part pic.twitter.com/EG5eVzOedU
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 18, 2020
UPDATE, March 18, 2020, 5:10 pm ET: Designed versions of the guidelines in Spanish have now been made available:
This is page 2 pic.twitter.com/k0l3X1aimt
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 18, 2020
About one hour later, a link to the Spanish-language version was posted to a White House URL. In addition, La Casa Blanca tweeted it out, as well as Vice President Mike Pence’s profile.
— La Casa Blanca (@LaCasaBlanca) March 18, 2020
15 Días Para Desacelerar La Propagación Del Coronavirus: pic.twitter.com/CUWY5i5pnA
— Mike Pence (@Mike_Pence) March 18, 2020
UPDATE, March 19, 4:45 p.m.: The Spanish version is now officially linked to White House’s section on new coronavirus guidelines:
Hey, all. The @WhiteHouse has officially added the Spanish language version of new #COVID19 guidelines on its site today.
It took 3 days for WH to add it but it's there now.
Thanks to all you shared my initial @latinorebels reporting on this.
LINK: https://t.co/LT02QE1xmF pic.twitter.com/V0QnJZwgcw
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 19, 2020
As of 5 p.m. ET on March 19, a check of Coronavirus.gov still doesn’t have a link to the official Spanish version:
And when you click on LEARN MORE on https://t.co/3mITWPkYBu, you just get the English ones for now.
Spanish is at https://t.co/no1b0JgYHy pic.twitter.com/UPgZv7ePaZ
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 19, 2020
UPDATE, March 19, 5:48 p.m. ET: The White House sent an email with the following information attributed to a White House official on background:
The White House disseminated Spanish-language guidelines on Tuesday to a multitude of reporters from Spanish and Hispanic outlets, whose collective reach is in the millions, and it was subsequently sent to more than a thousand leaders in the Hispanic and Latino communities. President Trump will continue to do everything he can to protect all Americans.
https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/coronavirus-guidelines-america/
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-nCoV/index.html
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prepare/prevention-sp.html
Some things to note about what White House said on Thursday afternoon and what was reported by Latino Rebels on Tuesday March 18:
This statement from WH official does not take that into account or any of what was shared or acknowledged on March 16 at night or on March 17 during the day.
So we ran that story and hours later on the 17th, Spanish version existed and was sent to Spanish-language media.
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 19, 2020
The statement does not take into account at all that a Spanish version did not exist on March 16, same day the English guidelines came out. WH knew they weren't available on March 16 when I asked. They knew.
— Julio Ricardo Varela (@julito77) March 19, 2020
As of this latest March 19 update, the Spanish guidelines still not on coronavirus.gov.
***
Julio Ricardo Varela is founder and publisher of Latino Rebels, part of Futuro Media. He tweets from @julito77.
[…] March 17, Latino Rebels confirmed that the latest March 16 White House/CDC guidelines are still not available in other languages, proving again that the pattern is […]
[…] currently not available in Spanish despite repeated claims from Latino groups to add a translation. Latino Rebels reporter Julio Ricardo Varela first reported the lack of a translation and later shared an update from the White House with a preliminary translation sent out to the […]
[…] BOLD PAC and NBC News both noted, Latino Rebels was first to notice the intentional discrepancy—and it’s intentional, all right: Latino Rebels reported […]
[…] health, 39% of Hispanics feel the same way. The White House was also criticized for not releasing CDC coronavirus guidelines until they were pressured by journalists and Latino […]
[…] Rebels founder/publisher and co-host of the “In The Thick” podcast, both part of Futuro Media, first reported that the new guidelines were not immediately released in […]
[…] issue in Philadelphia have implications at the national level. As journalist Julio Ricardo Varela wrote on Latino Rebels and NBC News later documented, the CDC and the White House have lagged far behind […]
[…] and have underlying health conditions, and guidelines for good hygiene and social distancing. Due to initial reporting by Latino Rebels’ Julio Ricardo Varela, which led to pressure from activist groups, the document was made available in Spanish two days […]
[…] barriers start with prevention. For a few critical weeks in March, The White House and the CDC websites were making the latest COVID-19 guidelines only available in English. Until late in March, the CDC […]
[…] issue in Philadelphia have implications at the national level. As journalist Julio Ricardo Varela wrote on Latino Rebels and NBC News later documented, the CDC and the White House have lagged far behind […]